Testing Framework

8-Week Launch Roadmap + Scaling

One element per test. Fixed tiers. NC CPA priority. Weekly creative read. Iteration pipeline from every winner.

Launch Campaign Structure (Week 1)

Structure

1 campaign, 1 ad set, $100+/day to start. Repurpose existing IG videos and statics as Meta ads before producing net-new.

First Move

Turn Sluff's existing IG reels and statics into Meta ads. Fastest path to learning with zero new production cost.

Founder Engine

Founder-led 9:16 verticals on every platform (social commerce snowball) as the organic layer feeding paid.

Flywheel

Product seeding at scale, TikTok Shop native first, usage rights secured, UGC flywheel compounding.

Launch Testing Roadmap (First 8 Weeks)

WeekAngleTest BatchVariantsPrimary MetricGate Check
1-2Founder Origin3 hooks × 9:16 Founder1.1, 1.2, 1.3Thumb Stop RateLP Hero fix (dynamic hero, founder presence, variant paths)
3-4Hidden Buildup3 hooks × 9:16 Expert/Customer2.1, 2.2, 2.7Thumb Stop + Link CTRLP Problem visual (beading demo, barrier animation)
5-6Disgustingly Satisfying3 hooks × 9:16 Customer3.1, 3.2, 3.7Thumb Stop + Hold RateLP Macro rolls (ASMR proof, visceral payoff)
7-8Western Care Skips Step3 hooks × 9:16 Expert/Founder/Customer4.1, 4.2, 4.9Link CTR + Purchases 25%LP Framework label (Prep → Sluff → Nourish)

Retargeting (Week 3+): Launch 15s hook cuts (Combo 11) for all winners. Scaling (Week 5+): Iteration pipeline from winners.

Testing Rules (Locked In)

One Element Per Test

Hook only. Angle, format, persona fixed per test batch. No confounding variables.

Test Batch Size

3 hooks per angle per format per persona. Minimum 7 days or 1,000 impressions per variant.

Statistical Significance

90% confidence or clear tier separation. No early calls on gut feel.

Kill Rule

Weak tier + below-average Thumb Stop = kill. Don't "optimize" dead creative.

Performance Tiers (Starting Assumptions)

TierCPA ThresholdNC CPA ThresholdThumb Stop RateAction
Strong<$20<$24>40%Scale: duplicate, increase budget 20-30%
Average$20-$30$24-$3625-40%Iterate: test new hooks, CTAs, shorter/longer versions
Weak>$30>$36<25%Scrap: if Thumb Stop below avg, replace hook. If Thumb Stop ok but weak, kill.

Assumption tag: These tiers are starting assumptions for a zero-paid-history brand. Sluff has no CPA baseline yet. Set the real tiers from Week 1-2 data before making kill/scale calls.

NC CPA Priority: If custom conversion exists, prefer NC CPA alongside blended CPA. NC CPA tells you if you're acquiring new buyers or just retargeting existing ones.

Custom Creative Metrics (SOP)

MetricFormulaWhat It RevealsBenchmark
Thumb Stop Rate3-second views / ImpressionsHook strength. Below average = replace hook.>35%
Purchases at 25%Purchases / 25% video viewsEarly-funnel convincing power>5%
Purchases at 50%Purchases / 50% video viewsMid-funnel conviction>3%
Purchases at 100%Purchases / 100% video viewsFull-view conversion power. Use for retargeting creative.>2%

Decision Rule: Funnel placement matters as much as creative quality. A comparison creative that underperforms on cold audiences (low Thumb Stop) can still convert strongly on warm/retargeting. Read creative at the funnel placement it runs, not just the raw numbers.

Offer / LP / Creative Gate (Run BEFORE Any New Hook Batch)

Gate Checklist

  1. Check offer first — Is the offer competitive? (discount, bundle, guarantee, shipping)
  2. Check LP second — Does LP match paid promise? (message match audit)
  3. Check creative third — Only rewrite hooks if offer + LP are solid

Sluff Current Offer Status

  • Offer: $48 Sluff It Kit (Bar + Mitt + Lotion)
  • Guarantee: 30-day satisfaction guarantee
  • Shipping: Free over $45
  • Discount: 10% off first order (signup-based; confirm exact code with brand before using in ads)
  • Competitive: Yes — $48 for 3-product system vs $10 commodity mitt (4-pack) or single products

LP Message Match Audit (Top 5 Planned Variants)

VariantHook MatchMech MatchVOC MatchOffer MatchPersona MatchBadge MatchScore
Founder Origin 1NYNYNY3/6
Founder Origin 2NYNYNY3/6
Hidden Buildup 1NYNYNN2/6
Disgustingly Satisfying 1NYYYNN3/6
Western Care Skips Step 1NYNYNN2/6

Gate Verdict: LP misaligned → fix LP first (hero headline, founder presence, variant-specific paths, "Prep → Sluff → Nourish" framework label, press quotes under logos, UTM-matched landing paths, CTA matching per variant)

Iteration Pipeline (12 Structural Variations)

For every winner, generate 12 structural variations — not just "refresh creative" but systematic expansion. This is the iteration pipeline. The SOP's 12-Combination System (4 emotional zones × 3 selves, Levinger) is a separate, deeper framework applied per winner; see the Creative Strategy Wiki for the full operating manual.

ComboStructural ChangeSluff Application
1Format swap (9:16 → 4:5)Winner Reel → Carousel / Feed static
2Persona swap (Customer → Founder)Customer UGC → Founder video (same hook)
3TEEP phase shift (TOF → MOF)TOF hook → MOF mechanism deep-dive
4Hook archetype swap (Story → Contrarian)Same angle, new hook type
5VOC phrase swap ("thousands" → "incorrectly bathing")Same angle, new verbatim
6Demo mechanism swap (macro rolls → absorption demo)Same proof, new visual
7Proof attribution swap (Customer → Derm → Press)Same claim, new authority
8CTA swap ("Shop Now" → "Fix Your Prep" → "See Routine")Same offer, new CTA
9Funnel placement shift (TOF → Retargeting)Winner TOF → RTG 15s hook cut
10Platform swap (Meta → TikTok)Winner Meta → TikTok Spark Ad
11Length adaptation (45s → 15s hook-only)Winner 45s → 15s retargeting cut
12Talent swap (Founder → Creator)Founder video → Whitelisted creator (same script)

Organic & UGC Flywheel (Feeds Paid)

Founder-Led Verticals

9:16 phone-shot founder content on every platform: brand story, what makes Sluff unique, answers to common questions, behind-the-scenes.

Seeding + Rights

Product seeding at scale. TikTok Shop native first. Secure usage rights fast, then deploy earned media across paid, site, and email.

Flywheel Loop

Track → Rights → Multi-Funnel Deploy → Analyze → Amplify. UGC embeds on-site (Tolstoy) to lift conversion and becomes the raw material for video ads.

Tooling

Refunnel runs the loop end to end (listening, campaigns, one-click whitelisting, payments). Trybe (jointrybe.com) for narrower performance UGC/whitelisting.

Weekly Creative Read Output Template

Creative Performance Memo — Week of [Date]

Top 5 Spenders (by Spend Share)

VariantSpend %CPA / NC CPAThumb StopPurchases at 100%TierAction
[Name]35%$18 / $2242%8%StrongScale +20%
[Name]22%$24 / $3131%5%AverageIterate hooks
[Name]18%$28 / $3528%3%AverageNew format
[Name]15%$35 / $4222%2%WeakKill
[Name]10%$19 / $2438%7%StrongScale +15%

Cascade Read

  • Platform KPIs: [CTR, CPM, CPA, ROAS trend]
  • Backend: [Net Sales, Contribution Profit, MER]
  • Verdict: [Creative / Offer / LP / Targeting bottleneck]

Iteration Pipeline

WinnerVariationNext VariantStatus
[Name]1 (format)[Name]-4x5In production
[Name]4 (hook)[Name]-H2Testing
[Name]9 (funnel)[Name]-RTGLive

Offer/LP/Creative Gate

[Gate output from checklist above]

Open Loops

  • [What would change this read]

Confidence Label

High / Medium / Low

Anti-Patterns (Enforced)

  • Testing multiple hooks per angle simultaneously
  • Calling "fatigue" on lifetime top performer without evidence
  • Blaming creative when cascade shows offer/LP break
  • No iteration pipeline (winners die after one format)
  • Emotional decisions without fixed CPA/ROAS tiers
  • No creative naming convention
  • Skipping Offer/LP/Creative gate
  • No NC CPA tracking
  • No weekly creative read

Creative Naming Convention (Established Day 1)

Platform# - Product - Creative Concept - Order# - Ratio

Examples:

  • 01 Sluff It Kit - Founder Origin 1 9x16
  • 01 Sluff It Kit - Founder Origin 2 9x16
  • 01 Sluff It Kit - Founder Origin 1 4x5
  • 02 Sluff It Kit - Hidden Buildup 1 9x16
  • 02 Sluff It Kit - Hidden Buildup 2 9x16
  • 01 Sluff It Kit - Founder Origin RTG 1 9x16 (retargeting)

Platform prefixes: 01=Meta, 02=TikTok, 03=YouTube Shorts, 04=Google Ads

Concept names (fixed): Founder Origin, Hidden Buildup, Disgustingly Satisfying, Western Care Skips Step, Comparison, Seasonal